Thursday, August 2, 2012

Miles civil case headed to jury - Pittsburgh Tribune-Review

Jordan Miles (right) enters the Federal Courthouse Thursday August 2, 2012 Downtown ahead of the start of jury deliberations in his civil lawsuit. James Knox | Pittsburgh Tribune-Review

By Brian Bowling

Published: Wednesday, August 1, 2012, 11:26 a.m.
Updated 8 minutes ago

Eight jurors on Thursday will begin deciding which version of a Homewood man’s 2010 arrest is more credible: His or the one described by the three Pittsburgh police officers who took him into custody.

Testimony ended Wednesday in the racially charged civil rights trial, and lawyers for both sides will make their closing arguments before U.S. District Judge Gary Lancaster sends the case to the jury.

Jordan Miles, 20, who is black, says he was walking along Tioga Street on Jan. 12, 2010, talking on a cell phone when the three white officers approached. Fearing he would be robbed or assaulted, he ran but slipped or fell and was beaten so severely he has permanent brain damage, he says.

The officers said Miles was lurking suspiciously between houses, appeared to have a gun and ran when they questioned him, eventually struggling and resisting arrest.

Officers Richard Ewing, Michael Saldutte and David Sisak deny violating his civil rights or that Miles suffered any permanent injury during the arrest. They admit to punching and kneeing Miles during the struggle to handcuff him but deny striking him afterward.

â€Å"Nobody ever choked him,” Ewing testified on Tuesday. â€Å"Nobody ever touched him after the handcuffs were on.”

An emergency room doctor who treated Miles the night he was arrested said the bump on his head and an adjacent cut could have been caused by the serrated edge of a police officer’s flashlight.

The officers called Dr. Thomas Martin, who worked for West Penn Hospital in 2010, to testify that some of the swelling of Miles’ face was attributable to a piece of wood that was driven into his gums during the arrest.

Miles contends the wood was on the ground and became lodged in his gums when the officers repeatedly pushed his face into the snow. The officers said the wood was part of a hedge and impaled Miles’ gums when Sisak tackled a fleeing Miles and they both went through the hedge.

Martin said Miles didn’t exhibit any signs of neurologic dysfunction during the hour and 20 minutes he was in the emergency room.

â€Å"Mr. Miles wouldn’t have fit the definition of concussion,” he said. Martin now works at UPMC Presbyterian.

Another emergency room doctor and a psychiatrist who treated Miles testified earlier in the trial that symptoms of brain injury don’t always show up immediately after the trauma. Martin agreed. He declined to comment after leaving the witness stand.

Other testimony on Wednesday was given by Miles’ manager at a CVS Pharmacy, who said that he is a good employee who has no difficulty at work. The three officers called the manager to show that Miles has not suffered any brain injury.

The officers also called Officer Lisa McCoy, part of the police department’s mobile crime unit, who testified about photographing the scene where the arrest occurred. And they called a police training expert who said that if the officers’ version of events is accurate, they followed proper police procedure, but if Miles’ version is accurate, they violated his rights.

The city settled Miles’ claim against it for $75,000, but as part of the agreement would pay any damages assessed against the officers if the jury finds for Miles.

Brian Bowling is a staff writer for
Trib Total Media. He can be reached
at 412-325-4301 or

You must be signed in to add comments

To comment, click the Sign in or sign up at the very top of this page.

There are currently no comments for this story.

Top News stories

1 killed, 3 hurt in early-morning shootings in Homestead 10:04 a.m.
By Margaret Harding
Two shootings that left one person dead and three hurt in Homestead are not â€Å"random acts,” police Chief Jeffrey DeSimone said Thursday. â€Å"I don’t think it’s random that you’re on the side of somebody’s house …
Man killed, another seriously hurt in head-on Fayette crash 8:48 a.m.
By Wpxi
A man was killed and another was seriously hurt when a truck and car crashed head-on in Fayette County Wednesday night. The crash happened just before midnight on Route 40 near Royal Road in Redstone …
None injured in early-morning Connellsville house fire
By Mark Hofmann
A house fire in Connellsville on Thursday morning drew firefighters from several departments, but no one was injured. Firefighters arrived at the …
Big Ben not bothered by partial rotator cuff tear
By Alan Robinson
Ben Roethlisberger ran downfield hard during a kickoff coverage drill, only to become locked up with a blocker. Steelers coach Mike Tomlin …
Second bike fatal on Penn Avenue spurs city action 
By Bobby Kerlik
Hours after the second fatal bicycle crash in a week, Pittsburgh officials said Wednesday they are setting up an alternate bike route …
Public safety director denies he withheld firefighter’s sick pay
By Tribune-Review
Public Safety Director Michael Huss on Wednesday denied in a federal court document that he withheld a retired Pittsburgh firefighter’s sick pay because the firefighter talked to the media about a public works snafu. David …
NCAA tabs former Sen. George Mitchell as PSU integrity monitor
By The Associated Press
STATE COLLEGE — Former U.S. Sen. George Mitchell will serve as the independent athletics integrity monitor at Penn State University for the …

Top stories

Chick-fil-A patrons turn out in support 9:09 a.m.
By Tony Larussa
Karen Shields never considered herself a regular customer of Chick-fil-A. On Wednesday, the Carrick woman became a convert. â€Å"I heard people were …
Kovacevic: Trevor Barron’s walk of life
By Dejan Kovacevic
LONDON — Walked about 4-5 miles Wednesday morning to meet with Bethel Park’s Trevor Barron at the Olympic Athletes’ Village. Moved pretty …
‘Golden Dragon’ floats on wings of connectiveness 9:48 a.m.
By Alice T. Carter
To Quantum Theatre artistic director Karla Boos, the rectangular concrete pond known as Lake Carnegie is a place of exquisite beauty. Costume …
Subscribe today & get the all digital eTRIB! Click here for our subscription offers.

No comments:

Post a Comment